Remove PayPal from Your Shopify Store ASAP!

In the ever-evolving world of eCommerce, offering the right payment options can make or break a customer’s experience. While PayPal has long been a staple in online transactions, it may no longer be the best fit for modern Shopify stores. Here’s why it might be time to remove PayPal as a payment gateway—and what you should use instead.

1. International Payments Are a Hassle

One of the biggest pain points with PayPal is how it handles international transactions. If you're selling globally, you may find that international payments often need to be manually captured through the PayPal dashboard. This adds unnecessary friction to your workflow and can lead to delays in order fulfillment, unhappy customers, and even lost sales.

Shopify’s native payment gateways, like Shop Pay, Google Pay, and Apple Pay, offer automatic payment capture, making the process seamless and efficient for both merchants and buyers.

2. PayPal Is Losing Relevance

PayPal’s dominance in the payment space is waning. With the rise of faster, more secure, and more integrated payment solutions, PayPal is starting to feel outdated. Many customers now prefer Shop Pay, which offers lightning-fast checkout and is deeply integrated into the Shopify ecosystem.

Other modern alternatives like Google Pay and Apple Pay are also gaining traction due to their ease of use, biometric authentication, and mobile-first design. These options are not only more secure but also more aligned with how consumers shop today.

3. Poor Integration with Shopify

While PayPal is technically supported by Shopify, the integration is far from perfect. Issues like:

• Manual payment capture
• Limited customization
• Disjointed refund processes
• Separate dispute resolution systems

...can make managing PayPal orders a headache. In contrast, Shopify Payments (which powers Shop Pay) offers a unified dashboard, streamlined refunds, and centralized dispute management, saving you time and reducing operational complexity.

4. Higher Fees and Hidden Costs

PayPal’s transaction fees can be higher than those of Shopify Payments, especially when dealing with currency conversions and international transactions. These hidden costs can eat into your margins over time.

By switching to Shopify Payments and enabling Shop Pay, you can benefit from lower fees, transparent pricing, and better control over your finances.

5. Better Customer Experience with Modern Gateways

Today’s shoppers expect speed, security, and convenience. Shop Pay, Apple Pay, and Google Pay offer:

• One-click checkout
• Biometric authentication
• Mobile optimization
• Faster processing times

These features lead to higher conversion rates, fewer abandoned carts, and better customer satisfaction—all critical for growing your Shopify store.

Matthew's Final Thoughts

While PayPal may still have a loyal user base, it’s no longer the most efficient or customer-friendly option for Shopify merchants. By removing PayPal and embracing modern payment gateways like Shop Pay, Google Pay, and Apple Pay, you can streamline your operations, reduce costs, and deliver a better shopping experience.

Ready to make the switch? Shopify makes it easy to enable these alternatives and start benefiting from a more modern, integrated payment ecosystem.

Let me help you join the future. Together, we’ll build a digital presence that reflects your brand, reaches new customers, and drives real growth.

Not on the Shopify Platform yet? As a Shopify Partner I can offer:
a Shopify website trial plan for FREE, then enjoy 3 months for $1 (click for details)

About the Author

Matthew Lester (Mathew/Mateo) is an accomplished 9+ year eCommerce professional specializing in Shopify store management, digital marketing, and design. Offers end-to-end support including SEO, UX optimization, analytics, app integration, and technical troubleshooting. Known for driving traffic and improving conversions. Also skilled in graphic design, photography, and business consulting such as why you should remove PayPal from your Shopify Store.



Matthew Lester Website Design
Shopify/SEO Expert & Graphic Designer
"Building you a better website."